LATESTFed minutesDollar todayHow to invest in bonds in Chile in 2026Chile's CMF reports three loan apps for extortion and usury
PAUTA FINANCIERA
Banks

CMF fines EY UF 1,200 over its audit of Hipotecaria La Construcción: what went wrong and what happened to the company

By ·

CMF fines EY UF 1,200 over its audit of Hipotecaria La Construcción: what went wrong and what happened to the company

Chile's Financial Market Commission (CMF) on Monday, November 16 fined the audit firm EY Servicios Profesionales de Auditoría y Asesorías Limitada UF 1,200 and its partner Daniel Zacharow Milleo UF 400 for breaching the Securities Market Law and Generally Accepted Auditing Standards (NAGA), according to the CMF statement (Resolution No. 12,262). At the November 16 UF (CLP 41,343.55), the fines are worth about CLP 49,612,260 and CLP 16,537,420.

The sanction in figuresCMF fines of November 16, 2026, in pesos at the day's UF
1,200Fine on EY (UF)
$49,612,260Fine on EY in pesos
400Fine on the partner (UF)
5%2021 transactions with seller complaints
View the data as a table
Fine on EY (UF)1,200
Fine on EY in pesos$49,612,260
Fine on the partner (UF)400
2021 transactions with seller complaints5%

What went wrong in EY's audit of Hipotecaria La Construcción

The sanction concerns the review of the 2022 annual financial statements of Hipotecaria La Construcción S.A. and its subsidiary Hipotecaria La Construcción Leasing S.A. (HLC). According to the CMF, those companies showed an "unusual and significant" decrease in accounts payable to third parties compared with 2021, and the audit did not investigate it with the care the law requires. The CMF listed four failures:

  • Insufficient analytical review: in some cases the auditors merely transcribed management's explanation, without further inquiry to corroborate it.
  • Weak tests of liabilities: they did not gather sufficient and appropriate evidence on the balances examined.
  • Internal control: they did not report the internal-control deficiencies they had detected to the board.
  • Ignored warnings: they did not properly consider an internal audit report that flagged complaints from home sellers affecting 5% of 2021 transactions.

"The work of external audit firms is essential for the reliability of the financial information that supervised entities report to the market and to the CMF," the regulator said (CMF). The resolution can be appealed before the Court of Appeals within the legal deadline, so it is not final.

Houses in Villa Nueva Quilín, Peñalolén
HLC financed homes with endorsable mortgages and housing leases. Photo: Gonzalo Orellana Hidalgo, Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 2.0).

What Hipotecaria La Construcción was and how it ended

HLC was a manager of endorsable mortgage loans and housing leases: it lent money to buy homes and then sold those loans to institutional investors. It claimed 35 years of experience in non-bank mortgage financing, according to Meganoticias. Its leasing subsidiary ran lease-to-own contracts for about 20 years and stopped signing new contracts at the end of 2022, according to Diario Financiero. To understand that product, see what housing leasing is.

The Hipotecaria La Construcción case
  1. 2008Grupo Pacal buys HLCAcquired from Eurocapital; linked to Pablo Castro Letelier.
  2. 2021Seller complaintsAffecting 5% of transactions, per an internal audit cited by the CMF.
  3. 2022Financial statements audited by EYUnusual drop in payables; leasing stops signing new contracts.
  4. Mar 2023Mismatch and forensic auditPayments to sellers do not match the loans; the company blames a scheme by colluding staff.
  5. Aug 2024CMF suspends HLCFor breaching the debt ratio; barred from granting or managing mortgages.
  6. Sep 2024Files for liquidationConsolidated debt of about 73,000 UF; the leasing subsidiary enters reorganization.
  7. Dec 2024Creditors approve the reorganizationOrderly sale of the leasing subsidiary's assets.
  8. Jan 2026Censure of HLC LeasingFor failing to file its 2024 financial statements on time.
  9. Nov 16, 2026Fine on EY and its partnerUF 1,200 and UF 400.

In March 2023 the company detected a mismatch between payments to home sellers and the amounts of the loans it had granted; a forensic audit revealed, according to the company itself, a fraud scheme by colluding employees, a version that is not a court finding (Meganoticias). In August 2024 the CMF suspended the parent company for breaching its debt ratio (CMF, August 27, 2024) and in September the company filed for voluntary liquidation, with liabilities above CLP 15,476 million, while its leasing subsidiary, with liabilities above CLP 7,000 million, entered judicial reorganization (Diario Financiero).

EntityReported liabilitiesStatusSource
Hipotecaria La Construcción S.A.Over CLP 15,476 millionVoluntary liquidation (Sep 2024)Diario Financiero
Hipotecaria La Construcción Leasing S.A.Over CLP 7,000 millionReorganization with orderly asset sale (Dec 2024)Diario Financiero
Consolidated groupSenior debt of about 73,000 UFMeganoticias

Does your law firm, audit firm or financial institution want to reach managers and directors? See Pauta Financiera's formats.

See advertising options

What the CMF fine means for borrowers and savers

  • It does not change your loans. The fine is on the audit firm; mortgage or lease contracts remain in force and payments go to whoever manages that portfolio today. If you are unsure who your creditor is, check your CMF debt report.
  • Auditors are accountable. The case shows that the CMF supervises not only lenders but also those who sign off on their balance sheets.
  • Outside banks, operational risk is higher. Mortgage managers and leasing firms are not banks and do not carry the state deposit guarantee. If you are looking for financing, compare rates and CAE in the best mortgages by bank.
Financial Market Commission office in Santiago
The CMF supervises banks, insurers, issuers and also external audit firms. Photo: Carlos yo, Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 4.0).

The same day, the CMF published an amendment to General Rule No. 426, which sets which minor infringements can go through a simplified sanctioning procedure; it only updates references to repealed rules and does not change the conduct covered, according to the regulator.

How to check whether a lender or its auditor is supervised by the CMF

The HLC case leaves a practical lesson: before signing a mortgage, a lease or an investment with an entity that is not a bank, it is worth checking which registry it belongs to and who audits its financial statements. The CMF keeps a search tool for supervised entities on its website, listing banks, mortgage managers, insurers, securities issuers and external audit firms, with their material events and financial statements.

  • Search for the entity by name or tax ID in the CMF search tool and check which registry it is in (for example, managers of endorsable mortgage loans).
  • Look at material events and sanctions: recent suspensions, censures or fines, like those HLC received in 2024 and 2026, are warning signs.
  • Read the auditors' report in the financial statements: if it has qualifications or emphasis paragraphs about going concern, ask before signing.
  • Compare with banks: bank rates and CAE are in our mortgage comparison and in how to refinance a mortgage if you already have one.

External audit firms that review securities issuers and supervised entities must be registered with the CMF and answer to it. That is why the sanction on EY does not fall on HLC, but on the quality of the review work. In HLC's case, both group companies are already in insolvency proceedings, so any claim by sellers or borrowers goes through those court processes.

Frequently asked questions about the CMF fine on EY

How large is the CMF fine on EY?

UF 1,200 for the firm and UF 400 for partner Daniel Zacharow Milleo, about CLP 49,612,260 and CLP 16,537,420 at the November 16 UF (CMF).

Why was EY sanctioned?

For deficiencies in auditing the 2022 financial statements of Hipotecaria La Construcción and its leasing subsidiary: insufficient evidence, failure to report control weaknesses and internal-audit warnings that were not considered (CMF).

What happened to Hipotecaria La Construcción?

The CMF suspended it in August 2024, it filed for liquidation that September and its leasing subsidiary approved a reorganization with an orderly sale of assets (CMF, August 27, 2024; Diario Financiero).

Is the fine final?

Not necessarily: CMF sanctions can be challenged before the Court of Appeals within the legal deadline.