LATESTFed minutesDollar todayHow to invest in bonds in Chile in 2026Chile's CMF reports three loan apps for extortion and usury
PAUTA FINANCIERA
Economy

Fund E: 53% blame the AFPs for the drop and 81% rate them poorly, even though the fund recovered 3.16% in October

By ·

Fund E: 53% blame the AFPs for the drop and 81% rate them poorly, even though the fund recovered 3.16% in October

Fund E's recovery in October was not enough to improve the AFPs' image. A Descifra poll, the alliance between Copesa and Artool, conducted on November 11-12, 2026 and published by La Tercera (Descifra poll), shows that 96% of respondents know about the controversy over the drop in the most conservative fund, that 53% blame the AFPs themselves and that 81% give them a grade of 1 to 4, compared with 61% in a similar April 2025 survey. Meanwhile, official figures from the Pensions Superintendency show Fund E returned +3.16% in real terms in October but is still down -7.56% so far in 2026.

Fund E and the AFPs in four figuresSystem real return to October 2026 and poll of November 11-12
3.16%Fund E in Octoberreal, UF-deflated
-7.56%Fund E January-October
53%Blame the AFPs
81%Give them a 1-4 grade61% in April 2025
View the data as a table
Fund E in October3.16%
Fund E January-October-7.56%
Blame the AFPs53%
Give them a 1-4 grade81%

Fund E: who is to blame, according to the poll

Fund E fell 10.4% through September because the AFPs lengthened their portfolio duration with US interest rate swaps, and when US rates rose the most conservative funds took the hardest hit, as explained in Fund E's swap losses. For respondents, the most questionable point is that the AFPs took excessive risks with a fund that was supposed to be conservative (45%), followed by the Superintendency not regulating earlier (24%) and the losses hitting mainly those who retired in recent months (18%). As responsible, they point to the AFPs (53%), the current government's Superintendency (23%) and the previous government's (12%) (La Tercera (Descifra poll)).

Who they blame for Fund E's drop% of respondents, November 11-12, 2026
View the data as a table
The AFPs53%
Superintendency (current government)23%
Superintendency (previous government)12%
Market fluctuations6%
Others4%

Communication did not convince either: 42% say they have not seen the AFPs answer the criticism and 38% think they explained it insufficiently; only 5% think they did so adequately. According to La Tercera, PlanVital is the only AFP that gave an interview on the issue and Capital answered questions in writing. 54% know the Superintendency opened sanction proceedings against the seven AFPs, and if a violation is confirmed, 73% prefer compensation or a refund of part of the losses to those affected, versus 19% who want the AFP's license revoked and 5% who prefer fines (La Tercera (Descifra poll)).

The case is widely known: 51% say they understand the controversy well, 33% moderately, 12% know of it but do not understand it well and just 4% have not heard of it. Faced with four statements, 95% agree that AFPs should have stricter controls on the funds of those close to retirement and 81% that they "gambled" with Chileans' savings. Even so, 67% acknowledge that AFPs invest in instruments that can have negative returns (La Tercera (Descifra poll)). Miguel Zlosilo, Descifra's methodology director, warned that the effect on the AFPs' reputation could be significant and endanger "part of what they gained after the withdrawals."

What respondents think of the AFPs% agreeing with each statement, November 2026
View the data as a table
Should have stricter controls for those about to retire95%
Gambled with pension savings81%
Invest in instruments that can have negative returns67%
Seek to maximize returns on all funds33%
AFPs' grade worsens in a year and a halfAFP rating on a 1-7 scale, % of respondents
Grade 1-4Grade 5-7
View the data as a table
Grade 1-4Grade 5-7
April 202561%39%
November 202681%19%
Santiago office towers at sunset
The Pensions Superintendency opened sanction proceedings against all seven AFPs over the Fund E case. Photo: Deensel, Wikimedia Commons (CC BY 2.0).

Fund E's 2026 return, month by month

Official figures confirm October's recovery but also the size of the blow. The system's Fund E rose +3.16% in real terms in October, after falling 4.92% in September and 3.26% in July; for the year it is down -7.56% and over 12 months -7.01%. At the other end, Fund A, the riskiest, is up 8.29% for the year despite losing 0.30% in October (Pensions Superintendency). Returns are real, that is, net of the UF's change.

Fund E had its worst month in SeptemberMonthly real return of the system, %, January to October 2026
Fund EFund A
-6%-4%-2%0%2%4%6%JanMarMayJulSepOctFund EFund A
View the data as a table
Fund EFund A
Jan-0.63%1.05%
Feb2.18%2.11%
Mar-0.86%-3.02%
Apr-1.20%4.82%
May-2.54%1.79%
Jun0.46%1.83%
Jul-3.26%-2.93%
Aug0.06%3.59%
Sep-4.92%-0.65%
Oct3.16%-0.30%
How much each multifund returns in 2026Cumulative real return January-October 2026, system, %
View the data as a table
Fund A8.29%
Fund B5.22%
Fund C-0.54%
Fund D-4.73%
Fund E-7.56%

Fund E by AFP: which fell most and least

The year's drop was not the same across managers. Through October, Habitat's Fund E loses the least (-7.09%) and Modelo's the most (-8.45%), according to the Pensions Superintendency. Who has earned the most with each fund over the long term is covered in AFP returns in 2026.

Fund E real return by AFP%, to October 2026; annual average since September 2002
Capital3.26%-7.85%-7.13%2.83%
Cuprum3.08%-7.67%-6.96%2.71%
Habitat3.25%-7.09%-6.61%2.90%
Modelo2.78%-8.45%-8.18%No data
PlanVital3.27%-7.16%-6.63%2.29%
ProVida3.17%-7.50%-7.08%2.40%
Uno2.94%-7.26%-6.70%No data
System3.16%-7.56%-7.01%2.70%
Modelo and Uno have no average since 2002 because they started operating later.Source: Pensions Superintendency
AFPOctober 2026January-October 2026
Capital+3.26%-7.85%
Cuprum+3.08%-7.67%
Habitat+3.25%-7.09%
Modelo+2.78%-8.45%
PlanVital+3.27%-7.16%
ProVida+3.17%-7.50%
Uno+2.94%-7.26%
System+3.16%-7.56%

Table source: Pensions Superintendency, UF-deflated real return, retrieved on November 15, 2026.

AFP ProVida branch
PlanVital was the only AFP to give an interview explaining the case, according to La Tercera. Photo: Rodrigo Fernández, Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 4.0).

Does your brand want to reach members who follow their pension funds and savings? See Pauta Financiera's formats.

See advertising options

What members believe about their fund, and what the data say

The poll also reveals a growing misunderstanding: 63% believe the money they will have at retirement comes mostly from their own contributions, versus 49% in April 2025, and only 15% think most of it is investment return. The Superintendency has shown that, for a representative member, one third of the fund is contributions and two thirds is return (La Tercera (Descifra poll)). That is why, for those far from retirement, a one-year drop weighs less than decades of returns: Fund E has averaged 2.70% real a year since 2002 (Pensions Superintendency).

  • If you retired under programmed withdrawal between July and September, you can request an extraordinary recalculation of your pension until December 31 (La Tercera). How the options compare is in life annuity or programmed withdrawal.
  • From 2027, the pension reform (Law 21,735) replaces multifunds A to E with generational funds assigned by age. 60% of respondents knew; 46% disagree with not being able to switch funds and 42% support it (La Tercera (Descifra poll)).
  • If you are comparing AFPs for voluntary savings, check fees and returns in the best AFPs for cuenta 2.

Frequently asked questions about Fund E

How much did Fund E return in October 2026?

+3.16% in real terms for the system average, ranging from +2.78% (Modelo) to +3.27% (PlanVital) (Pensions Superintendency).

How much has Fund E lost in 2026?

-7.56% in real terms between January and October. Through September the drop was about 10.4% (Pensions Superintendency; La Tercera (Descifra poll)).

Should I switch funds?

It depends on your age, horizon and risk tolerance. Frequent switching can make you sell after a drop and miss the recovery, like October's. This story is informational and not financial advice.